Cuatro amigos de los scouts, una tienda de campaña y una regla que nunca debía romperse
It was Saturday the 6th of February 2021 on the high crest of the Appalachin Trail in Great Smoky Mountains National Park at the TriCorner Knob Shelter on the North Carolina side near the Tennessee state line.
Four young men were inside a single tent pitched on a relatively level patch of ground in the area around the shelter with snow and strong wind moving across the high ridge above them.
They were at the shelter listed on their itinerary.
At some point after that, and nobody can say precisely when, nobody who loved them would ever hear from any of them again.
Their names were Caleb Adley, 22, Isaiah Blake, 21, Grant Leman, 23, and Evan Shaller, 22, and they had all grown up in Ketering, Ohio, a suburb just south of Dayton.
They had joined the same scout troop within about a year of each other when they were 11 and 12, and they had stayed in it all the way through high school, which is less common than people think.
They had all aged out of the troop years earlier, but they still thought of themselves as part of the same scout family.
Three of them made Eagle Scout.
Evan stopped one rank short, and the other three gave him a hard time about it for years, which he took in good humor.
The troop met on Tuesday nights in the basement of a Lutheran church on the east side of town, and it was the kind of troop that went camping in January on purpose.
Every winter they went to a Klondike Derby, a scout event where patrols [music] pull sleds through the snow from station to station, building fires and tying knots and doing first aid in the cold.
And all four of them had slept out in Ohio winters more times than they could count.
At 16, they had done a trek together at Filmont, the big scout ranch in New Mexico, and their families later remembered that trip as one of the things that turned four boys from the same church basement into four people who would drive across three states for each other.
I want you to understand these weren’t four guys who’d watched a couple of videos and brought some [music] gear.
They had years of organized camping and winter outdoor experience behind them.
By the winter of 2021, they were four young adults scattered, the way friends from a hometown usually end up.
Grant was working at an engineering firm in Columbus and had just signed a lease on his first apartment.
Caleb was finishing a nursing degree in Cincinnati and had already been offered a job in an emergency department, which is a detail his family finds very hard to talk about.
Isaiah and Evan were both in their last year of college, one in Kentucky and one back home in Dayton.
The pandemic had kept them apart for most of the year before, and the Smoky’s trip was the thing they had been talking about in their group chat since the summer.
The first time all four of them would be in the same place in more than a year.
Isaiah’s older sister has said that when the dates were finally set, he printed the permit and taped it to his fridge.
Caleb’s mother has said he spent most of January testing his new sleeping bag on the back porch in Cincinnati, texting the group a photo of the thermometer every morning, and that the other three sent back photos of theirs just to argue about whose porch was colder.
The plan was a 4-day section of the Appalachian Trail through the north end of the park, starting at Newfound Gap and walking north along the crest to Davenport Gap near the Tennessee and North Carolina line where the trail leaves the park.
It is one of the most beautiful stretches of the whole trail.
High and narrow and remote, running along the spine of the mountains for miles with almost no road access at all.
The Smokies require a backcountry permit for overnight trips.
And on the Appalachian Trail inside the park, hikers are generally expected to stay in the trail shelters.
Their permit, which was later recovered, listed a shelter for each night.
Pex Corner on the Friday, TriCorner Knob on the Saturday, Cosby Knob on the Sunday, then out to Davenport Gap on the Monday morning where they had left a second car.
Under the park’s ordinary rules, permit holders with a shelter listed on their itinerary are required to stay inside it.
But beginning in March of 2020, the park’s temporary CO era rules allowed backpackers with shelter reservations to use a tent outside the shelter instead for social distancing.
and that temporary allowance was still in place in the winter of 2021.
It meant they could legally use the tent outside the shelter during that period.
Tricorn Knob is worth knowing about.
It is often described as one of the most remote shelters in the park.
A three-sided log shelter sitting high on the crest near Mount Guio, a long way from any road in every direction.
On a clear day, that is the whole appeal of it.
In a storm, it is a very long way from anything.
The crest of the Smokies up there does not look like the rest of the park.
Most of the Smokies is thick hardwood forest, but the highest ridges are a different world.
Spruce and fur, dark and close together with moss, roots, and patches of snow covering the ground.
A lot of the old Fraser furs up there were killed off decades ago by a tiny invasive insect.
And in places the ridge is still dotted with their gray bare trunks.
In winter, when the cloud sits on the ridge and the wind drives freezing fog through the trees, branches and dead trunks can become coated in a thick white crust of rhyme ice.
It is one of the most beautiful things you will ever see.
And on that exposed ridge, it can be a sign of persistent freezing fog, wind, and icing.
They made it to that shelter safely.
I keep dwelling on that one fact there because it’s exactly what makes the rest of this so hard to believe.
What they carried is well documented because Grant was the kind of person who made a spreadsheet for everything and he had shared it with the group chat the week before.
Each of them had a full winter kit.
Down jackets, insulated pants, rainshells, two pairs of gloves each, sleeping bags rated well below freezing, closed cell foam pads as well as inflatable ones.
They carried a fourperson winter tent that belonged to the troop, which Grant had borrowed for the trip, and a small twoperson tent as a backup.
They had a paper map of the park, a compass, a headlamp each with spare batteries, a first aid kit Caleb had packed himself, and two small canister stoves with enough fuel for 4 days of cooking and melting snow.
They each carried a pair of traction spikes that stretch over the bottom of your boots for walking on ice.
The list covered the major winter essentials: insulation, shelter, navigation, lighting, first aid, and cooking.
The only thing on Grant’s spreadsheet that anybody later looked at twice was a small note he had added at the bottom reminding everyone to keep their fuel canisters from getting so cold that stove performance suffered since a very cold canister can lose pressure and produce a weak or unreliable flame.
It showed that someone in the group had considered the effect of cold temperatures on stove performance.
Walt Hoer ran their troop for most of the years they were in it.
He is in his late 60s now and still lives in Ketering.
And he later spoke publicly about the four of them.
He said that if he had been asked to pick four young men from his entire time as a scoutmaster who he would trust in the back country in winter, those four would have been on the list.
He also said something when he spoke about them that he has repeated since and it is the reason this story is as hard as it is.
He said the scout’s safety guidance on this point was explicit.
that fuel burning equipment was not to be used inside a tent.
Not a stove, not a candle, not a heater, nothing.
He personally drilled that rule into every patrol he ever ran.
And he said it has been written into scouting safety rules for a very long time.
No flames inside a tent ever.
These four had that one rule drilled into them for years in scouting, and they’d heard it more times than they could count.
The first night went exactly to plan.
They set off from Newf Found Gap on Friday morning in cold winter weather.
Grant’s phone, which was recovered later, has photographs from Charlie’s Bunion, a bare rocky outcrop a few miles in where the ridge drops away on one side, and you can see for miles across the Tennessee side of the park.
There are pictures of all four of them sitting on the rock with their packs off, squinting into the sun, Evan pretending to fall off the edge while the other three laugh.
They reached Pec’s corner in the late afternoon.
There was one other person staying at the shelter that night, a retired school teacher from Asheville named Terry Ballard, who was out for a few days on his own.
He gave a statement to park rangers the following week and later spoke to a reporter.
He said the four of them were loud and happy and very clearly old friends and that they were better organized than most of the people he meets in winter.
He said they cooked outside under the overhang of the shelter the way you are supposed to and that one of them offered him hot chocolate.
He said they talked about the forecast which was calling for a system moving in on the Saturday with snow and strong wind on the high ridges and that they had decided to push on to try corner knob anyway because it was a relatively short second day on paper and they wanted to be settled at the shelter before it arrived.
He said that seemed reasonable to him and that he would probably have made the same call himself at their age.
He said he told them he was heading back south in the morning and wished them luck and that Caleb said they had an Eagle Scout for every corner of the shelter so they would be fine.
the last person to spend the night with them said they were the best prepared group he’d met all winter and even after knowing what happened to them.
I don’t think he was wrong.
Here is the thing about weather on the crest of the Smokies in winter and it is the thing people from outside the region almost never expect.
These are not tall mountains by western standards.
But the high ridges run above 6,000 ft in places and the weather up there can behave very differently from the weather in Gatlinburgg or Cherokee a few thousand ft below.
A system that looks manageable in the forecast can arrive faster and harder on the ridge than it does in the valleys.
And the trail along the crest is exposed in a way that the lower trails are not.
A winter weather system moved through the region that weekend with snow developing as temperatures fell.
As far as anybody can tell, it was not unusual for February in the Smokies.
On the high crest, it brought snow and strong wind, and that was more than enough to change what a comfortable night looked like.
Newfound Gap Road is vulnerable to closure in that kind of weather, which can complicate access to that part of the park.
Terry Ballard said they left Pex’s Corner a little after 9 on the Saturday morning, later than he would have liked, but not late, and that the sky was already going gray to the west.
There was no record of anyone seeing them after that.
What happened on the Saturday afternoon comes from a single text message and from the physical evidence found afterward.
At 3:40 that afternoon, Caleb sent a message to his mother.
The high ridges of the Smokies have very patchy cell coverage and the message appears to have gone out during one of those brief moments when a phone catches a signal.
It said they had made it to try corner knob that the weather was getting bad and that they were going to sleep in the tent outside the shelter.
It said they were all fine.
It ended with love you talk Monday.
His mother still has it on her phone and she has said she has never been able to bring herself to delete it.
I’ve read that last text more times than I’d like to admit.
Word for word it said, Made it to try corner.
Kent’s going up outside the shelter.
All good.
Love you.
His mother has said she read it and felt relieved because to her it sounded exactly like the kind of sensible plan she would want him to have.
And by every standard anybody could apply that afternoon, it was a sensible plan.
Reaching the shelter before the worst of the weather, getting a tent up, getting everybody warm and dry is what any experienced hiker would tell you to do.
The trouble was not the plan.
It was what happened after they settled in.
The tent was pitched on a relatively level patch of ground in the immediate area around the shelter where the temporary CO era rules allowed tents to be used.
They had pitched the fourperson winter tent, the one that belonged to the troop.
The smaller twoerson backup tent was later found still packed in Evans backpack rolled tight in its stuff sack exactly the way it had been at the start of the trip.
The reason they chose the tent instead of the shelter cannot be established from the surviving evidence.
The pandemic era rules allowed them to tent outside and they had brought the winter tent for that purpose.
One possible explanation is that the enclosed tent offered more protection from wind-driven snow, but there is no evidence showing that was their reason.
The tent was rated for four people, so it could accommodate all four of them.
Although winter gear and packs would have made the interior crowded.
Here is what searchers found inside that tent’s vestibule.
The small covered porch at the front where you normally keep your boots and your pack out of the rain.
one of the two canister stoves with a pot on it.
The fuel canister was empty.
The tent door had been zipped shut.
The vestibule had been closed against the wind.
Every one of them was inside in their sleeping bags.
The scene strongly suggested that the stove had been operated inside the enclosed vestibule, but the physical evidence could not establish exactly where it had been running.
It is worth explaining what that means because a lot of people do not know it.
A fuel burning stove operating inside an enclosed tent or vestibule can produce dangerous carbon monoxide concentrations, [music] particularly when ventilation is limited.
Carbon monoxide has no smell, no color, and no taste.
You cannot see it, and you cannot feel it arriving.
It binds to your blood far more readily than oxygen does, and as it builds up, it can cause headaches, dizziness, nausea, confusion, and drowsiness.
The degree of ventilation that night cannot be established from the surviving evidence.
Snow around the tent or blocked vents could have reduced air exchange, but that too would have to remain a reconstruction.
That’s what makes this so horrifying to me.
People who are asleep can die from heavy carbon monoxide exposure before they even recognize the danger.
Nobody knows exactly how long the stove was running or [music] whether it was being used only to melt snow or also to take the edge off the cold.
Nobody knows who lit it or who zipped the vestibule shut.
And I am not going to guess.
All four had been taught the rule repeatedly during their years in scouting.
What the evidence shows is a closed vestibule, an empty canister, and all four ultimately found inside the tent.
One commenter who grew up backpacking in the 60s said, You never hike alone and you should always carry a whistle around your neck.
Regardless of if you grew up outside, or if you haven’t, we’ve all received similar advice from our parents.
But what bothers me is that these four were never alone and they had whistle.
That commenter’s advice is [music] common wilderness safety advice, and it is good advice.
The two pieces of advice in that comment were followed.
They were found together with no evidence indicating they had separated during the period investigators could reconstruct, and all four had whistles.
Some of their backpacks had a whistle built into the buckle of the sternum strap, the small strap that clips across your chest.
Caleb also had a separate orange safety whistle clipped to his pack, the kind scouts are told to carry, and three short blasts are a commonly taught emergency signal.
A whistle can carry farther than an ordinary voice in some conditions, uses little energy, and does not get horsearse.
There is no indication that any whistle was used.
A whistle, phone, or map is most useful when somebody recognizes that something is wrong and is able to act on it.
The silence on Sunday did not immediately trigger an emergency call.
Caleb had said they expected to talk Monday, [music] and the family’s new cell coverage in those mountains was unreliable.
The Monday came and went, too.
They had been due to walk out at Davenport Gap that morning, pick up the car they had left there, and drive back to Newf Found Gap for the other one.
Evan had told his mother they would stop for pancakes in Gatlinburg on the way home.
By Monday evening, when none of the four had answered their phones, Grant’s father called the park using the contact information on the permit.
He has said the ranger who took the call asked him careful questions about the permit, the cars, and the text message, and that the calmness of it frightened him more than anything.
Within a couple of hours, a ranger had driven to Davenport Gap and confirmed that the second car was still sitting there, covered in snow, exactly where they had left it on the Friday morning.
It’s worth pausing on how long that gap was because it’s the part of the story that the families have struggled with most.
Caleb’s text went out on Saturday afternoon.
The first call to the park came on the Monday evening.
The delay is consistent with the itinerary they had provided since their planned exit was Monday and that is simply how long a backcountry plan takes to become overdue when the text says talk Monday.
Rangers began the overdue person response that evening checking the vehicles and reviewing the permit information.
Because of darkness, winter conditions, and the distance to the shelter, the main ground teams were staged for a first light push.
Getting to them was another matter.
The section of trail they were on is about as far from road access as it is possible to be in the Smokies.
And that distance would shape almost everything about the days that followed.
The search that began on the Tuesday was led by National Park Service rangers with trained search and rescue personnel and cooperating agencies from both Tennessee and North Carolina, and they approached the section from both ends of the planned route, calling out and blowing whistles at intervals along the way, then stopping to listen and hearing nothing but wind.
By Tuesday morning, family members had begun arriving in the park and waiting for updates.
Evan’s mother has said the rangers told the families that four fit, well-equipped young men had a good chance of being holed up somewhere waiting out the weather and that the families wanted to believe it.
The permit and Caleb’s text gave search managers a strong starting point.
Try corner knob.
What made it hard was everything between the searchers and that shelter.
Low cloud, snow, and the terrain also limited aerial searching, and the spruce and fur up there can make a small tent hard to pick out from above.
Every team carried overnight gear because nobody on that crest could be sure of getting back down in a day.
Teams approaching from Davenport Gap had to climb steeply from the lower elevations toward the nearly 6,000 ft crest, and fresh snow could obscure sections of the trail and make route finding slower.
By the end of the Tuesday, a team approaching from Davenport Gap had reached Cosby Knob and found no sign of the group, but darkness and conditions kept it from continuing south toward Tricorner Knob that evening.
Each empty shelter gave search managers another piece of information, but Tri Corner remained the critical gap in the middle of the search.
It sits roughly 16 mi north of Newfound Gap and roughly 15 mi south of the Davenport Gap trail head, close to the middle of the route.
Which is why remote is not just a figure of speech for that shelter.
Teams working north from Newfound Gap reached PC’s Corner on the Tuesday and found the shelter log book, the notebook hikers write in at trail shelters with a Friday entry in Evans handwriting, four names, and a line about hot chocolate.
It confirmed the first night and told searchers nothing more.
Searchers knew exactly which shelter they were headed for, and it still took days to get there.
That’s how remote this stretch of the Smokies is.
By the Wednesday, conditions had eased enough for teams to move along the crest more quickly.
Late Wednesday afternoon, the first crew to reach the Tricorner Knob shelter found the tent, a green shape, partly buried in windblown snow on the level patch of ground near the shelter.
Searchers later said it was sagging under the weight of the snow that had fallen on it and that there was no answer when they called out.
They noted afterward that it had been pitched carefully with the guidelines staked out the way anybody in that troop would have been taught.
The crew radioed it in, secured the area, and rangers on the crew were the first to open it.
Searchers who were there have said the hardest part was the silence.
The wind was still moving through the spruce around the shelter.
The tent was completely still.
It is a fair question why nobody else found them sooner.
No witness account or search documentation identified another party reaching that shelter before the search crews did.
At some point after the Saturday afternoon text, Caleb Adidley, Isaiah Blake, Grant Lehman, and Evan Shaller all died inside that tent just outside the Tricorner knob shelter.
The scene investigation found the stove and the empty canister in the enclosed vestibule, and postmortem toxicology found elevated caroxyhemoglobin levels in blood samples from all four, which is the measure of carbon monoxide bound to the blood.
The medical examiner concluded that carbon monoxide poisoning was the cause of death for all four based on the toxicology findings together with the stove, the fuel canister, and the enclosed tent scene.
There were no traumatic injuries that explained the deaths and no documented evidence that any of them had left the tent after it was pitched.
They were 21, 22, 22, and 23 years old.
Searchers later described the scene as initially looking like four people asleep in their sleeping bags.
Searchers knew exactly which shelter they were headed for and it still took days to get there.
That is how remote that stretch of the Smokies is.
The families kept most of the details private.
What has been shared, they have shared deliberately and most of it has been shared for one reason, which is that they want other people to hear it.
It is worth being exact about what this reconstruction rests on.
[music] The plan comes from the permit, which was recovered with their belongings.
The gear comes from Grant’s own packing spreadsheet and from what was found at the campsite.
The first night comes from Terry Ballard’s statement.
The Saturday afternoon comes from Caleb’s text message.
The exact location of the tent comes from the campsite itself and its relationship to the shelter.
The physical scene comes from the photographs, observations, and evidence documented by the search crew.
And the cause of death comes from the medical examiner’s findings and post-mortem toxicology.
What nobody can establish is how long the stove burned, whether any of them woke up and realized what was happening or exactly when each of them died.
Those are gaps and I am leaving them as gaps.
The families later held a joint memorial in Ketering that spring in the same church whose basement the troop had met in for all those years.
Somebody laid out the patches and sashes and merit badges the boys had earned.
And near the end of one table, somebody had set out four orange safety whistles in a row.
Evan’s mother asked the scouts in the room to remember one thing, that no flame goes inside a tent, and that the vestibule counts as inside.
Isaiah’s sister spoke.
So did Grant’s father, who told the room that his son had once made him practice tying a bow line in the kitchen until he could do it with his eyes closed.
Terry Ballard, the retired teacher who shared the shelter with them that Friday, drove up from Asheville for the memorial and stood at the back of the room.
He has said that he thinks about the hot chocolate.
He has said he has gone back over that evening many times looking for anything he saw that should have worried him and that he has never found it.
They cooked outside.
They talked about the weather sensibly.
Nothing Terry recalled from that Friday suggested the group was in any difficulty.
If anything, he has said they were more careful than he was that trip, and he has been hiking in the Smokies for longer than they had been alive.
Whatever happened the following night occurred a day later, several miles farther along the trail in a tent he never saw.
Walt Hoffer still teaches the no flames intense rule to the scouts he volunteers with.
And he has said he teaches it differently now.
He used to say it as a rule, the way it is written, the way it was said to him.
Now, he said he tells them this story and he watches the room go quiet.
The scouts in the troop today ask him about the four of them, and he tries to answer their questions.
If there’s one thing to take from this, it’s that the rules that sound obvious are often there because the danger behind them is easy to underestimate.
Stay safe and I’ll see you next
Cr: Wild Stories With Joshua